Magic Toybox is a community-driven toy and puzzle library based in Williamsburg, VA.
Instead of buying expensive games that gather dust, enjoy access to a rotating library of puzzles and classics — all handled locally. No accounts, no shipping — just good games, passed hand-to-hand.
We're currently running this as a local pilot. If you're nearby and interested, reach out — we’ll match you with the perfect game night.
Locals only (for now) — Williamsburg, VA and nearby.
From Monopoly to Ticket to Ride and Catan, we carry a growing list of favorites.
500-piece or 1000-piece, relax with a puzzle at your own pace. Swap it out when you’re ready.
We meet neighbors, share recommendations, and support local families with fun that doesn’t break the bank.
We're currently onboarding a small group of testers. Submit your email and we'll be in touch.